PCIe / CXL Debug: Review Checklist

Review checklist

Review Checklist for PCIe / CXL Debug focuses on link degrade event count, completion timeout rate, poison/error log. The goal is to connect the observable symptom to protocol mechanism, ownership, and regression risk.

• Spec revision and implemented feature subset are named.

• Clock/reset and CDC assumptions are reviewed.

• Traffic classes, IDs/tags, ordering, and outstanding limits are documented.

• VIP/compliance coverage maps back to requirements.

• Performance metric and debug artifact are stored with the signoff note.

• Owners signed: debug lead, firmware owner, controller owner.

Sign-off ownership

OWNERSHIP MAP — PCIe / CXL Debug

evidence type        owner who reads it
-----------------    ---------------------------
waveform/RTL        debug lead
spec/VIP            firmware owner
firmware/system     controller owner

Rule: every metric must have a named owner before a review starts.

Protocol deep dive

PCIe is reliable packet delivery over unreliable links; debug flows PHY -> DLL -> TLP -> firmware.

Concept diagram

PCIe DEBUG TOP-DOWN

L0 link healthy?  -> credits OK?  -> TLP completes?  -> driver happy?

Skip a layer and you will mis-own the bug.

Metric graph

LINK DEGRADE EXAMPLE

target x4 Gen4  ---- ---- ---- ----
actual   x4 Gen4  ---- ---- ---- ----   (eval board)
actual   x1 Gen3  -                   (product board)

Package/SI often shows up as width downgrade, not hard fail.

Metrics and artifacts to collect

• link width/speed

• replay count

• completion timeout

• AER error log

• LTSSM history

Mini case study

Endpoint enumerated but DMA timed out: completion credits exhausted because a switch port was misconfigured in firmware, not because the endpoint was broken.

Debug branches

• If degrade at width/speed, PHY/SI before driver.

• If replay storm, link layer before transaction layer.

• If CXL coherency bug, separate .io vs .cache vs .mem traffic.

Senior review question

Ask: what is the first transaction that deviates, and which spec rule does it test?

Key takeaways

• Connect every protocol claim to a transaction identity and measurable metric.

• Store the artifact (waveform, log, counter) next to every signoff decision.

Common pitfalls

• Debugging timeouts without finding the first bad transaction.

• Quoting peak bus width without payload efficiency and retry overhead.

• Treating VIP compliance as a substitute for system integration replay.

Principal review addendum

Re-read PCIe / CXL Debug against one concrete product workload, not a synthetic directed test.

debug starts at link health, then checks packet credit, ordering, firmware resource allocation, and endpoint behavior.